Fresh pizza
Fresh Β· Authentic Β· Delivered Hot

Life's Too Short for Bad Pizza

Wood-fired pies crafted with love, made-from-scratch dough, and the freshest toppings from local farms.

Wood-Fired Oven

Our 900 degree oak-fired oven creates the perfect char and chew on every crust.

Award-Winning

Voted Best Pizza in the City three years running by local food critics.

Fast Delivery

30-minute delivery guarantee or your next order is on us. Every time.

Fresh Ingredients

Locally sourced toppings, hand-crushed San Marzano tomatoes, daily-made dough.

Fresh From the Oven

Hand-picked favourites from our kitchen - made fresh daily with the finest ingredients.

House Salad

Lettuce, tomatoes, carrots, and croutons

Meat Pizza

Your choice of 5 meats on an 18″ deep dish

Chesse Pizza

Large 18″ Chesse Pizza

36+
Years Open
50+
Menu Items
4.9
Star Rating

From Nonna's Kitchen to Your Table

The Scariest Slices in Town Since 1987. What started as a small family kitchen has grown into the neighbourhood's most beloved pizzeria - but our recipes, values, and passion haven't changed a bit.

  • Made-from-scratch dough proofed for 48 hours
  • Hand-crushed San Marzano DOP tomatoes
  • Locally sourced, seasonal toppings
  • Mozzarella pulled fresh every morning
  • Baked in our original 1989 wood-fired oven
Order Now

News, Recipes & Stories

Tips, recipes and stories from Scary Gary's kitchen.

Visit Us or Order Online

Whether you're dining in, picking up, or want us delivered to your door - we'd love to hear from you.

Address
123 Main Street
New York, NY 10001
Phone
+1 (555) 123-4567
Email
hello@scarygaryspizza.com
Hours
Mon-Thu: 11am - 10pm
Fri-Sat: 11am - 11pm
Sun: 12pm - 9pm